New York Attorney General Settlement with Facebook Creates New Model to Protect Children Online

In follow-up to our earlier blog post regarding recent pressure on social networking sites from law enforcement, New York Attorney General Andrew Cuomo announced yesterday that his office had entered into a settlement with Facebook. The settlement resolves the Attorney General’s investigation of Facebook’s failure to fulfill public claims it made about protecting minors, which the Attorney General believed were deceptive acts and practices and false advertising in violation of New York consumer protection laws. Facebook did not admit to any wrongdoing.  

Continue Reading...

Social Networking Sites Feel The Heat From Law Enforcement

Kids like social networking sites, most notably MySpace and Facebook. So it is not surpising that law enforcement is scrutinizing how the sites protect children. Recent subpoenas issued to Facebook by New York Attorney General Andrew Cuomo and New Jersey Attorney General Anne Milgram are illustrative.

Both subpoenas sought information about Facebook’s Internet safety and security policies. The New York subpoena, issued last month, also sought information concerning Facebook’s complaint resolution procedures. In its subpoena cover letter to Facebook, Attorney General Cuomo noted Facebook’s public representations concerning how it responds to reports of pornographic material and inappropriate contact with minors.  It also described its undercover investigation of Facebook. According to the letter, the investigation revealed pornographic and other inappropriate content readily available on the site. In addition, after investigators set up profiles as young teenage users, they received inappropriate sexual advances. The investigators filed complaints about these issues through Facebooks’ complaint procedures. The letter notes various instances of non-responsiveness or delayed response to such complaints. The New Jersey subpoena issued earlier this month, described here, sought information from Facebook concerning convicted New Jersey sex offenders that Facebook has identified as site users.  Facebook previously informed the New Jersey Attorney General it had removed sex offenders with profiles matching individuals listed on the New Jersey sex offender registry. Attorney General Milgram also sent letters to eleven other social networking sites requesting they compare their registrants against the state’s sex offender list.     

Continue Reading...

Governor Schwarzenegger Says No to California A.B. 779

On Saturday, California Governor Arnold Schwarzenegger vetoed AB 779, legislation that would have amended California’s landmark data security breach legislation. The bill would have been the first to follow law enacted by Minnesota earlier this year and effective August 1, 2007, discussed here, that amended Minnesota’s security breach notification law by, among other things, prohibiting businesses from retaining certain payment card data after authorization of a transaction.

As discussed in our previous posts here and here, AB 779 was proposed in the wake of the massive security breach at the TJX Companies and would have prohibited businesses that sell goods or services to any resident of California and that accept as payment credit cards, debit cards, or other payment devices from, among other things, storing, retaining, sending, or failing to limit access to payment-related data, and from storing sensitive authentication data subsequent to an authorization, unless a specified exception applied. The bill also incorporated certain liability-shifting provisions that would have made such businesses liable to the owner or licensee of the information for the reimbursement of reasonable and actual costs of providing notice to consumers as required by existing law and for the reasonable and actual cost of card replacement as a result of the breach of the security of the system. It also would have mandated the inclusion of specific kinds of information about a breach in notices provided to individuals affected by the breach.

Continue Reading...

International Privacy Issues and More Addressed in New International Practice Guide

Proskauer Rose LLP has just released "Proskauer on International Litigation and Arbitration: Managing, Resolving, and Avoiding Cross-Border Business and Regulatory Disputes." The online guide is a practical reference work for businesses and practitioners; it explores best practices and creative yet practical approaches to manage, resolve, and avoid controversies affecting multiple jurisdictions. 

The 28-chapter guide is available free in e-Book format at www.proskauerguide.com. It includes a thorough chapter on international privacy law.

Continue Reading...

French Data Protection Agency Rules that Employees Are Entitled to View Their Evaluations

 

Earlier this year, CNIL, the French Data Protection Agency, issued a ruling that changed the confidentiality treatment accorded to employee evaluations under French law. CNIL ruled that employees must be able to review any evaluations written about them by their employers. The CNIL issued the ruling after receiving several complaints from employees of an (anonymous) multinational company, which refused to divulge the employees’ evaluations to employees upon request.

Continue Reading...